Are We All Born Atheists?

Are newborn babies really atheists? A Vaiṣṇava presuppositional response argues that our reliance on logic, truth, and morality points toward an inherent knowledge of Kṛṣṇa—even before we consciously recognize Him.

Are newborn babies really atheists? A Vaiṣṇava presuppositional response argues that our reliance on logic, truth, and morality points toward an inherent knowledge of Kṛṣṇa—even before we consciously recognize Him.

The text argues against the assumption that logic is a valid epistemic tool, claiming it lacks grounding without a divine source. It contends that both atheism and flawed logic lead to radical uncertainty and ultimately fail to justify knowledge. In contrast, a theistic worldview, particularly one anchored in divine revelation, provides a firm foundation for understanding truth and reason.

Claiming we can't know God because He's acintya (inconceivable) totally misses the mark. In Vaisnavism, sure, God’s full nature is beyond our complete understanding—but think about it: if He's almighty, He controls exactly how much He reveals about Himself.

Given naturalistic evolution, the chances that our cognitive faculties are genuinely reliable for apprehending truth appear low or practically indistinguishable from unreliability. Here’s how this likelihood unfolds under naturalistic assumptions:

Atheistic thinkers employ several philosophical arguments in their attempt to justify that trusting our senses and cognitive faculties in their pursuit of knowledge is possible in the absence of a theistic framework. These arguments generally fall into different epistemological approaches, such as empiricism, rationalism, and pragmatism.

"The concept of truth, i.e. the idea that statements and beliefs express propositions that correspond to reality and states of affairs, cannot be accounted for in the absence of God."

The text argues that all experience exists within consciousness, challenging materialism's claim that matter is mind-independent. Materialism fails to explain the nature of matter or consciousness, treating matter as unknowable. In contrast, a theistic framework positions consciousness as fundamental, providing a coherent explanation of reality and our understanding of both consciousness and matter.

By Ajit Krishna Dasa Krishna consciousness is self-authenticating (svatah-pramana). It cannot be independently proven by any outside evidence. It is itself the only ultimate foundation of all evidences and proofs. So without presupposing the truth of God as He is…